Is it cheaper to replace or rekey locks

March 12, 2024

Is it cheaper to replace or rekey locks

Welcome to our guide on the age-old question: Is it cheaper to replace or rekey your locks? As experts in the field of locksmithing, we understand the importance of security for your home or business. Your locks are the first line of defense against intruders, and ensuring they are in optimal condition is paramount. However, when faced with the decision to replace or rekey your locks, many factors come into play.


In this comprehensive blog post, we'll delve deep into the intricacies of lock replacement versus rekeying. We'll explore the costs associated with each option, consider the factors that influence the decision-making process, and weigh the pros and cons of each approach. By the end of this guide, you'll have a clear understanding of which option is best suited to your needs and budget.


Whether you're a homeowner looking to upgrade your security or a business owner seeking to protect your assets, we're here to provide you with expert advice and guidance. So, without further ado, let's dive into the fascinating world of locks and locksmithing, and uncover the answer to this age-old question.


Read more about How to extract a broken key from a lock?


Understanding Lock Replacement and Rekeying


Lock Replacement

When it comes to lock replacement, you're essentially swapping out your existing locks for brand new ones. This process involves removing the old lock hardware entirely and installing new locks in its place. While lock replacement may seem like a straightforward solution, it comes with its fair share of considerations. Firstly, the cost of purchasing new locks can vary depending on the type, brand, and quality of the locks you choose. Higher-grade locks with advanced security features will naturally come with a higher price tag. Additionally, the installation process itself can be labor-intensive, especially if you're dealing with multiple locks or specialized hardware. However, the upside of lock replacement is that you have the opportunity to upgrade to more secure, modern locks that better suit your security needs. Plus, you'll have the peace of mind knowing that your property is outfitted with brand new, reliable locks that haven't been subjected to wear and tear.


Lock Rekeying

Lock rekeying offers a cost-effective alternative to lock replacement, especially if your existing locks are still in good condition. Instead of replacing the entire lock mechanism, a locksmith can rekey the existing locks to work with a new set of keys. This process involves altering the internal components of the lock cylinder so that it no longer responds to the old key but instead operates with a new one. One of the key advantages of lock rekeying is that it allows you to maintain the existing hardware and aesthetics of your locks while enhancing security. Additionally, rekeying is typically a quicker and less labor-intensive process compared to lock replacement, resulting in lower overall costs. It's also a convenient option if you want to maintain key control without having to distribute new keys to everyone who has access to the property. Overall, lock rekeying offers a practical solution for updating your security without breaking the bank.


Read more about How does the type of lock affect the complexity of the rekeying process?


Factors Influencing Cost:


  1. Number of locks involved: The total number of locks that need to be replaced or rekeyed will directly impact the overall cost. Generally, the more locks you have, the higher the cost will be, as each lock requires individual attention and labor.
  2. Type and complexity of locks: The type and complexity of the locks in question also play a significant role in determining the cost. High-security locks or specialized lock systems may require more time and expertise to replace or rekey, resulting in higher costs compared to standard locks.
  3. Accessibility and location of locks: The accessibility and location of the locks within your property can affect the cost of replacement or rekeying. Locks that are difficult to access or located in hard-to-reach areas may require additional time and effort to work on, potentially increasing the overall cost of the service.


Average Cost Estimates:


  1. Typical cost range for lock replacement: On average, the cost of replacing a single lock can range from $50 to $200, depending on factors such as the type of lock, brand, and complexity of installation. For multiple locks or high-security locks, the cost can increase accordingly. It's essential to factor in both the cost of the new locks themselves and the labor involved in installation.
  2. Typical cost range for lock rekeying: Rekeying a lock is generally a more cost-effective option compared to replacement. On average, the cost of rekeying a lock can range from $20 to $100 per lock. However, this cost can vary depending on factors such as the type of lock, the number of pins to be changed, and the locksmith's labor rates. Overall, rekeying offers a more budget-friendly alternative for updating your security while retaining existing hardware.


Considerations for Decision Making


A. Condition of Existing Locks

  • Whether existing locks are in good condition or need replacement due to damage or wear: Assessing the condition of your current locks is crucial in determining whether replacement or rekeying is the best option. If the locks are still in good working order and only the keys need to be updated, rekeying may suffice. However, if the locks show signs of damage, such as rust, corrosion, or mechanical issues, replacement might be necessary to ensure optimal security.

B. Security Requirements

  • Whether security needs warrant a complete lock replacement or rekeying is sufficient: Consider your security requirements and whether rekeying alone will meet those needs. If you're looking to upgrade your security system or if there have been security breaches in the past, replacing the locks with higher-security options may be the better choice. On the other hand, if security concerns are minimal and you're primarily looking to update access control, rekeying might be a suitable and more cost-effective solution.

C. Budget Constraints

  • Considering the budget available for the lock-related expenses: Budgetary considerations play a significant role in the decision-making process. Rekeying is generally more affordable than lock replacement since it involves less labor and materials. If you're working within a tight budget, rekeying may be the more feasible option. However, if security concerns or the condition of existing locks warrant replacement, allocating additional funds for new locks may be necessary to ensure the safety and security of your property.


Pros and Cons


A. Pros of Lock Replacement

  • Provides new, updated locks with enhanced security features: One of the main advantages of lock replacement is the opportunity to install new locks with advanced security features, such as high-security cylinders or smart lock technology. This can significantly enhance the security of your property and provide peace of mind.
  • Eliminates concerns about old or damaged locks: Lock replacement ensures that you're starting fresh with brand-new locks, eliminating any concerns about the condition or reliability of existing locks. This can be particularly beneficial if your current locks are outdated, damaged, or showing signs of wear and tear.


B. Cons of Lock Replacement

  • Higher cost compared to rekeying: One drawback of lock replacement is its higher cost compared to rekeying. Since it involves purchasing entirely new locks and possibly hiring a locksmith for installation, the overall expense can be significantly higher, especially if you have multiple locks to replace.
  • Requires installation of new hardware: Lock replacement typically involves installing entirely new hardware, including locksets, strike plates, and possibly even door handles or hinges. This can be more time-consuming and labor-intensive compared to rekeying, especially if the new hardware requires modifications to the door or frame.

C. Pros of Lock Rekeying

  • Cost-effective option, especially for multiple locks: One of the primary benefits of lock rekeying is its cost-effectiveness, particularly when dealing with multiple locks. Since rekeying only involves changing the internal pins and tumblers of the lock cylinder, it is generally a more affordable option compared to lock replacement.
  • Retains existing hardware and aesthetics: Unlike lock replacement, which requires installing new hardware, rekeying allows you to retain your existing locksets, strike plates, and other hardware. This can be advantageous if you're satisfied with the current aesthetic of your locks or if you have hardware that matches the overall design of your property.


D. Cons of Lock Rekeying

  • May not address underlying issues with old or damaged locks: While rekeying can update the keying system of a lock, it does not address any underlying issues with the lock itself. If your locks are old, damaged, or malfunctioning, rekeying alone may not fully resolve these issues, potentially leaving your property vulnerable to security risks.
  • Limited security enhancement compared to lock replacement: While rekeying can improve access control by rendering old keys useless, it does not provide the same level of security enhancement as lock replacement. If you're looking to upgrade your security system with new, high-security locks, rekeying may not suffice.


Conclusion

In conclusion, the decision between lock replacement and rekeying depends on various factors, including your security needs, budget constraints, and the condition of your existing locks. Lock replacement offers the advantage of installing new, updated locks with enhanced security features, but it comes with a higher cost and the need for new hardware installation. On the other hand, lock rekeying is a more cost-effective option that retains existing hardware and aesthetics, but it may not fully address underlying issues with old or damaged locks and provides limited security enhancement. Ultimately, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option and choose the one that best suits your individual circumstances and preferences.

Call Us Any Time!

Call Now
By Youmna Rehman October 12, 2025
Upgrading your old mechanical lock to a smart lock can boost security, convenience, and control. Learn how to assess compatibility, choose the right smart lock, install it correctly, and maintain it for long-term safety. Expert tips from Brothers Locksmith for a seamless smart home upgrade.
By Youmna Rehman October 12, 2025
Thinking about using a universal key duplicator? Learn the real risks behind these devices — from security breaches and poor-quality copies to legal issues. Discover why trusting certified locksmiths like Brothers Locksmith is a safer, smarter way to handle key duplication and security.
How to Recover a Lost Digital Key Stored in Your Phone
By Youmna Rehman October 8, 2025
Lost your digital key stored on your phone? Learn how to recover it using cloud backups, app reactivation, or locksmith help. Brothers Locksmith offers 24/7 assistance for digital key recovery, reprogramming, and lockout emergencies.
Can a Locksmith Help if Your Car Key Fob Is Water-Damaged?
By Youmna Rehman October 6, 2025
Wondering if a locksmith can fix your water-damaged car key fob? Discover how water affects key fobs, what to do immediately after damage, and how Brothers Locksmith can repair, reprogram, or replace your fob quickly and affordably — anytime, anywhere.
How to Prevent Key Fob Relay Attacks on Modern Cars
By Youmna Rehman October 6, 2025
Modern vehicles are wonderfully convenient — push-button starts, keyless entry, and digital fobs make daily life easier. But convenience creates new attack surfaces. A key fob relay attack is a type of theft where criminals amplify or relay the signal from your car’s key fob so that the vehicle “thinks” the fob is nearby and unlocks or starts. In recent years, these attacks have grown in frequency because they can be carried out quickly with relatively inexpensive equipment. The result: owners return to find their car gone and insurance claims that are messy and stressful. Understanding how relay attacks work and what you can do to prevent them is essential for every modern car owner. How Mobile Apps Are Revolutionizing Automotive Lock Services What Is a Key Fob Relay Attack? A relay attack uses two devices and two attackers (or one attacker with two devices). One device is placed near the car to capture signals; the other is placed or carried near the house where the legitimate key fob is stored. The devices communicate, relaying the key fob’s signal to the car so it behaves as if the owner is standing next to it. Once the vehicle is unlocked, thieves can often start it and drive away. Importantly, the criminals don’t need to hack encryption or physically touch the key — they simply extend the fob’s wireless presence. Why Keyless-Entry Systems Are Vulnerable Keyless systems were designed for convenience, not to withstand the creative methods thieves now employ. Many fobs broadcast low-power radio signals that are sufficient for short-range use but can be picked up and boosted. Manufacturers added rolling codes and encryption to combat simple replay attacks, but relay attacks bypass these protections by forwarding the live signal rather than replaying a recorded one. Additionally, vehicles that rely purely on proximity checks without additional authentication are intrinsically more exposed. Signs Your Car May Have Been Attacked Detecting a relay attack can be tricky because it often leaves little forensic. However, there are clues to watch for. If you find your car unlocked with no sign of forced entry, or if the vehicle is missing and there’s no broken window or tow evidence, a relay attack is a prime suspect. Unexplained battery drains in your key fob, or the car responding when the fob is nowhere nearby, can also be early warning signs that someone has tampered with the wireless environment around your home or vehicle. Practical Steps You Can Take Right Now Prevention starts with small habit changes that greatly reduce your risk. The most immediate step is to stop leaving the fob next to an exterior door or in a coat pocket by the entrance. Criminals commonly position relay devices just outside front doors and windows to capture signals from fobs left on hallway tables. Keep your fob in a signal-blocking pouch (Faraday pouch) or a metal container when at home. These inexpensive items prevent radio waves from being transmitted and are widely available. If you don’t have a pouch, placing the key fob inside a microwave or a metal tin temporarily will also block the signal. Store spare fobs away from doors and windows — ideally in a central area of the house or inside a Faraday-lined container. Disable passive entry if your car allows it. Many vehicles offer a setting to turn off walk-up unlocking so the doors only unlock when you press the fob. This removes the always-on proximity behavior that relay attacks exploit. Similarly, when possible, configure your car to require the fob to be present and a button press on the fob for engine start rather than only relying on proximity detection. For overnight or extended parking, lock your car in a locked garage if available. A physical barrier — a door that must be opened to access the vehicle — adds a layer attackers must overcome and makes relay operations much more difficult in practice. Technology and Hardware Countermeasures Manufacturers and aftermarket vendors have introduced technical mitigations. Some carmakers are implementing motion- or sleep-sensing in fobs so the fob only transmits when it’s moving, drastically reducing the window of opportunity for relay attacks. Others use time-of-flight or angle-of-arrival radio techniques to estimate the physical distance between fob and vehicle more accurately, making it harder to spoof proximity. Aftermarket signal-blocking products, hardened steering-wheel locks, and wheel clamps still serve as effective physical deterrents. You can combine a Faraday pouch for daily storage with a visible mechanical deterrent such as a steering wheel lock when parking in public or in high-risk neighborhoods. Evidence shows opportunistic thieves are less likely to attempt thefts where the effort and time required are clearly higher. If you want a robust, manufacturer-level solution, check whether your carmaker offers a software update or an optional accessory that strengthens authentication. Some newer vehicles support phone-based digital keys that use secure elements and require biometric unlock on the phone — this stacks additional layers of security beyond raw radio proximity. Can a Locksmith Recover a Lost Digital Lock Passcode? Best Practices for Key Fob Handling and Car Storage Always carry the key fob on your person rather than leaving it at home during travel. Don’t stash spares in obvious places such as glove compartments, under the car, or in external boxes — thieves know where people hide keys. For families, distribute access carefully: issue digital keys with time-limited permissions if your vehicle supports it, rather than sharing physical fobs with everyone. When parking overnight on the street, choose well-lit and busy locations with camera coverage if possible. Public CCTV and visible neighbors act as deterrents. For short errands, keep windows up and doors locked; even if the vehicle remains unlocked, a thief is less likely to approach a car that sits in a visible, active environment. Vehicle Settings and Software Hygiene Just as you update your phone, keep your vehicle’s firmware and key fob software current. Many automakers release patches that adjust how fobs communicate or add new anti-tampering logic. Check your owner’s portal or dealer communications for recalls and security bulletins. If your car supports disabling passive entry, consider turning it off or using it selectively. Finally, avoid installing untrusted aftermarket modules that interact with the vehicle network, as poorly coded devices can introduce new vulnerabilities. How Dealers and Locksmiths Can Help A trusted dealer or certified automotive locksmith can assist in multiple ways. Professionals can check whether your vehicle has a passive-entry disable option and help configure it. They can evaluate key fob battery health and sensor alignment to reduce accidental transmissions. If you suspect your fob is compromised or malfunctioning, locksmiths can reprogram or replace the fob, and where possible, pair it with motion-sensing variants that minimize broadcast windows. At Brothers Locksmith , we specialize in automotive security services and can provide fast on-site diagnostics, key fob programming, and advice on the best physical and technical deterrents for your model. If a relay attack has occurred, our technicians can assist with immediate steps to secure replacement keys and recommend anti-theft upgrades. Advanced Detection and Forensics Detecting a relay attack after the fact can be challenging but not impossible. Some advanced systems and security services can scan for suspicious RF activity near your home or car. RF detectors can identify nearby devices operating on typical key fob frequencies. If you have reason to believe you’ve been targeted, a professional sweep can reveal anomalies that ordinary users won’t notice. For high-risk situations — fleets, high-value vehicles, or corporate car parks — consider installing monitoring solutions that log remote unlock requests and correlate them to time, location, and user credentials. Logging creates an audit trail which can be invaluable for investigations and insurance claims. Insurance, Liability, and Reporting Theft If your car is stolen via a relay attack, contact local law enforcement immediately and file an insurance claim with as much detail as possible. Document anomalies such as lack of forced entry, missing or damaged key fobs, and any RF detection logs if available. Some insurers are updating policy terms around keyless thefts, so consult your provider on coverage specifics and required safeguards. Keeping records of any security improvements — like Faraday pouches or steering locks — can demonstrate you took reasonable precautions. Community and Neighborhood Measures Prevention is easier together. Neighborhood watch groups and communities can spread awareness about relay attacks and encourage household practices like storing fobs centrally and using Faraday pouches. Businesses with parking lots can invest in CCTV and physical barriers or attendants who check vehicle access. Public awareness campaigns by local authorities or police can reduce the number of successful attacks simply by making thieves’ methods less effective through education. The Future: Where Vehicle Security Is Heading Vehicle security is evolving. Manufacturers are exploring multi-factor authentication for keyless systems, combining proximity with user biometrics or phone-based secure elements. Quantum-resistant cryptography and secure enclaves in smartphones could harden digital keys dramatically. Meanwhile, carmakers may more widely adopt distance-measurement techniques to validate a key’s true location. For owners, this means upgrades and retrofits will become available over time to retrofit older models with stronger authentication methods. When to Call a Professional If you notice unexplained unlocks, excessive key fob battery drain, or your car is missing without signs of forced entry, call a professional immediately. A qualified automotive locksmith can reprogram keys, assess whether your fob is leaking, install hardware anti-theft devices, and recommend best-in-class countermeasures for your car model. For immediate emergency response, Brothers Locksmith provides 24/7 automotive locksmith services, including on-site key replacement and security assessments. Practical Checklist: Quick Actions You Can Take Today Store your key fob in a Faraday pouch or metal container at home. Disable passive entry if your vehicle allows it; otherwise turn off auto-unlock features. Park in secured, well-lit, or attended areas whenever possible. Use a visible mechanical deterrent (steering wheel lock or wheel clamp) for added delay and deterrence. Keep vehicle and fob firmware updated and check with your dealer for security patches. Consider motion-sensing or low-broadcast fobs when replacing worn units. If targeted, document everything, notify police, and contact your insurer promptly. Why Brothers Locksmith Can Help You Stay Secure Keyless theft is a modern problem, and modern solutions are required. Brothers Locksmith blends automotive locksmith expertise with up-to-date knowledge of wireless vulnerabilities. Our technicians can program and replace key fobs, advise on passive-entry settings, install physical anti-theft devices, perform RF sweeps when required, and offer practical everyday advice to reduce your risk. If you’re in Houston or Albam and want fast, professional help, our 24/7 emergency automotive locksmith line is available to you. Conclusion: Practical Vigilance Beats Panic Relay attacks exploit predictable behaviors and convenience features. The good news is that with a few practical changes and modest investments — Faraday pouches, motion-sensing fobs, disabling passive entry, and visible mechanical deterrents — you can greatly reduce your risk. Staying informed, maintaining your vehicle and fobs, and partnering with trusted professionals like Brothers Locksmith will keep your car safer in a world where wireless theft techniques continue to evolve.
Why Does My Smart Lock Randomly Unlock Itself?
By Youmna Rehman October 2, 2025
Worried your smart lock unlocks on its own? Learn the common causes, security risks, and expert solutions to keep your home or business safe from unexpected access.
Predictive Locksmithing: How Data Analytics Improves Security
By Youmna Rehman September 30, 2025
Explore how predictive locksmithing uses data analytics to prevent lock failures, enhance security, and provide smarter protection for homes and businesses.
How AI-Powered Surveillance Integrates With Smart Locks
By Youmna Rehman September 30, 2025
Discover how AI-powered surveillance and smart locks work together to boost home and business security. Learn about benefits, challenges, and the future of intelligent access control.
More Posts