Best Places to Stash a Spare Key

December 26, 2024

Keeping a spare key is a practical solution to avoid the frustration and inconvenience of getting locked out of your home or car. However, where you choose to stash this spare key is crucial. A poorly hidden key can be an open invitation for intruders, while a well-thought-out hiding spot can ensure peace of mind and accessibility. This guide explores the best, most secure places to hide a spare key while balancing safety and practicality.



7 Ways Locksmiths Keep Your Home Safe While You Travel


Why Choosing the Right Hiding Spot Matters

When hiding a spare key, the objective is to keep it accessible yet out of reach for burglars. Many people make the mistake of placing their keys in obvious spots like under the doormat or a flowerpot near the door, which are the first places thieves check. A well-hidden spare key ensures you have a backup in emergencies without compromising the security of your property.


1. With a Trusted Neighbor or Friend

The safest place to keep a spare key is not on your property but with someone you trust. Whether it’s a neighbor, friend, or family member, handing over a key ensures it won’t be found by an intruder. Ensure this person lives nearby and is someone you can rely on during an emergency.


Why It’s Effective:

  • No physical hiding spot on your property for burglars to find.
  • Immediate access in emergencies, provided the person is available.

Consideration:
Ensure they’re available during odd hours if you might need the key unexpectedly.


2. Magnetic Key Box on Your Car

For car keys, a magnetic key box can be attached underneath the vehicle in a less conspicuous location. These boxes are durable, weatherproof, and can blend seamlessly with the car's undercarriage.


Why It’s Effective:

  • The key remains hidden but easily accessible when you’re locked out of the car.
  • Mobile solution for those constantly on the move.

Pro Tip: Avoid attaching the box near the exhaust or any heated components to prevent damage to the key.


3. Fake Rocks or Outdoor Decorations

A fake rock designed to hold a spare key is a clever way to stash it in plain sight. Modern versions are realistic and can blend seamlessly with your landscaping.

Why It’s Effective:


  • Blends in with the natural surroundings.
  • Easily accessible if placed thoughtfully.

Placement Tip: Avoid placing the fake rock too close to the entryway, as this could draw attention. Instead, integrate it into a garden or near a tree.


4. Hidden Compartments in Outdoor Furniture

Outdoor furniture often has hidden compartments or spaces underneath where a key can be stashed securely. For instance, under the cushion of a patio chair or inside the base of a planter.


Why It’s Effective:

  • These spots are not immediately obvious to anyone looking for a key.
  • Dual-purpose use of outdoor furniture.

Consideration: Ensure the area is weatherproof to prevent damage to the key over time.


5. Inside a Lockbox

A lockbox is a small, secure device that can be mounted near your door or hidden elsewhere on your property. These boxes require a combination code to open, making them a safe option for spare key storage.


Why It’s Effective:

  • Intruders cannot access the key without knowing the code.
  • Can be placed inconspicuously, such as behind a planter or on a side wall.

Pro Tip: Regularly change the code for added security.


6. Under a Deck or Behind a Fence Post

For homes with decks or fences, the nooks and crannies underneath or behind these structures offer discreet hiding spots. Use a waterproof container to protect the key from the elements.


Why It’s Effective:

  • Less obvious to burglars compared to traditional hiding spots.
  • Keeps the key out of sight but within reach.

Placement Tip: Choose a location that isn’t overly cluttered, so you don’t struggle to find the key when needed.


7. Attached to Your Pet’s Collar

For pet owners, attaching a spare key to your dog or cat’s collar is an innovative and mobile solution. Most burglars won’t think to check a pet for a key.


Why It’s Effective:

  • Always moving and not stationary like a traditional hiding spot.
  • Only accessible to those familiar with the pet.

Consideration: Ensure the attachment is secure and doesn’t cause discomfort to your pet.


8. Inside a Weatherproof Electrical Outlet Cover

Empty electrical outlet covers can be repurposed as discreet hiding spots for spare keys. These covers blend seamlessly with the exterior of your home and are unlikely to attract attention.


Why It’s Effective:

  • Invisible to intruders unless they specifically check outlet covers.
  • Protects the key from weather damage.

Placement Tip: Install an additional, non-functional outlet in a strategic location specifically for this purpose.


9. Inside a Secure Garage

If you have a garage, consider hiding the spare key inside, such as on a high shelf, behind tools, or in a labeled but unrelated container.


Why It’s Effective:

  • Keeps the key indoors, away from potential thieves.
  • Accessible if the garage itself has an alternate entry method.

Consideration: Ensure the garage is always locked to maintain security.


Common Mistakes to Avoid When Hiding a Spare Key

  • Under the Doormat: This is the first place anyone, including burglars, will check.
  • Inside a Mailbox: While convenient, it’s too exposed and often targeted.
  • Near Windows: Placing keys close to windows makes it easy for intruders to find and use them to gain entry.


Conclusion

Choosing the right place to stash a spare key is about finding a balance between accessibility and security. By selecting creative hiding spots like magnetic boxes, fake rocks, or trusted neighbors, you can ensure that your spare key is there when you need it without compromising the safety of your property. Brothers Locksmith encourages you to explore secure and innovative solutions for spare key storage to keep your home and family safe.

Call Us Any Time!

Call Now
By Ghulam Mustafa April 7, 2026
Learn how to fix door gaps that weaken lock security, prevent forced entry, and improve door alignment without replacing your entire lock system.
By Ghulam Mustafa April 6, 2026
Smart locks promise convenience. Keyless entry. Remote access. Control from your phone. But when it comes to security, one question still confuses many homeowners: Can you rekey a smart lock the same way you would a traditional one? Or are you stuck replacing the entire system? The answer isn’t as simple as yes or no. Because not all locks—smart or traditional—work the same way. And understanding that difference can save you time, money, and unnecessary upgrades. Start With What Rekeying Actually Means Rekeying isn’t about changing the outside of a lock. It’s about altering what happens inside. In a traditional lock, rekeying changes the internal pins so old keys no longer work. The hardware stays the same, but access is completely reset. It’s one of the most efficient ways to regain control—especially after moving into a new home or losing a key. But this process depends on one thing: A physical key mechanism. And that’s where smart locks start to differ. Why Traditional Locks Are Easy to Rekey Standard deadbolts and cylinder locks are built for it. Their internal pin systems are designed to be adjusted, reconfigured, and reset without replacing the entire lock. A locksmith can quickly change the key combination while keeping the same exterior hardware intact. This is why rekeying has always been the go-to solution for restoring security without overspending. It’s simple. Direct. Reliable. And in most cases, it’s all you need. What Makes Smart Locks Different Smart locks aren’t just locks. They’re systems. Some rely entirely on digital access—keypads, apps, or biometrics. Others combine smart features with a traditional key cylinder. That distinction matters. Because you can’t “rekey” something that doesn’t use a physical key in the first place. Instead of pins and tumblers, fully digital locks rely on codes, permissions, and software-based control. So the way you reset access changes completely. Can Smart Locks Be Rekeyed? It Depends on the Type If your smart lock includes a physical key override, then yes—part of it can be rekeyed. The mechanical cylinder inside can be adjusted just like a traditional lock. A locksmith can change the key access without affecting the smart features. But if your smart lock is fully keyless, there’s nothing to rekey. In those cases, security is managed digitally. You simply delete old codes, reset access permissions, or perform a factory reset. No hardware changes required. Just a different kind of control. Why Digital Resetting Replaces Rekeying in Smart Systems With traditional locks, control comes from keys. With smart locks, control comes from access management. Instead of worrying about who has a physical copy, you manage: Who has a code When they can enter How long their access lasts If someone no longer needs entry, you don’t rekey. You remove them. That shift is what makes smart locks powerful—but also why people misunderstand how to secure them properly. When Rekeying Still Matters in a Smart Lock Setup Even if you use a smart lock, the physical key backup shouldn’t be ignored. That override exists for a reason. Power failures. Technical glitches. Dead batteries. In those moments, the mechanical key becomes your fallback. If that key has been copied, lost, or shared in the past, rekeying the cylinder is still essential. Because digital security means nothing if the physical backup is compromised. Should You Rekey or Replace a Smart Lock? Not every situation requires a full replacement. If your concern is access control, resetting codes or permissions is usually enough. If your concern is physical key security, rekeying the cylinder solves the problem. Replacement only becomes necessary when the lock is damaged, outdated, or no longer reliable. The mistake most people make is jumping straight to replacement—when a simple reset or rekey would have done the job. The Hidden Risk: Forgetting Old Access Points Whether it’s a traditional lock or a smart one, the real issue is often the same: Too many people have access. Old tenants. Previous owners. Contractors. Guests. With traditional locks, that risk lives in duplicated keys. With smart locks, it lives in forgotten codes and active permissions. If you don’t actively reset and review access, your lock—no matter how advanced—stops being secure. When to Call a Professional If you’re unsure whether your smart lock includes a rekeyable cylinder, or if it’s not functioning properly, it’s worth getting expert input. A locksmith can assess your setup, identify whether rekeying is possible, and ensure both your digital and physical security layers are aligned. Professionals like Brothers Locksmith often handle hybrid systems, where both smart features and traditional mechanisms need to work together seamlessly. Because real security isn’t about choosing one or the other. It’s about making sure every layer does its job. Final Thoughts Rekeying isn’t outdated. It’s just evolving. Traditional locks rely on it. Smart locks replace it with digital control. And hybrid systems use both. The key is understanding what kind of lock you actually have—and how it manages access. Because security isn’t about the label on your lock. It’s about who can still get in. And whether you’ve taken the time to change that.
Why Some Keys Work Better When Inserted Upside Down
By Ghulam Mustafa April 5, 2026
Discover why keys sometimes work better upside down, what it reveals about lock wear or misalignment, and how to fix the issue before it leads to lock failure.
Can You Rekey Smart Locks or Only Traditional Ones?
By Ghulam Mustafa April 3, 2026
Learn whether smart locks can be rekeyed or only traditional ones, and how to reset access, improve security, and avoid unnecessary lock replacement.
Why Your Door Lock Feels Loose After Door Repairs
By Ghulam Mustafa March 31, 2026
Why your door lock feels loose after repairs and how to fix it. Learn the real causes and smart ways to restore security without replacing the lock.
How to Secure Older Homes Without Replacing Every Lock
By Ghulam Mustafa March 30, 2026
How to secure an older home without replacing every lock? Discover smart, cost-effective ways to upgrade home security while preserving existing hardware.
Why Keyless Entry Pads Stop Responding
By Ghulam Mustafa March 30, 2026
Why do keyless entry pads stop responding? Learn the common causes, quick fixes, and when to call a locksmith to restore your smart lock system.
What to Do If Your Lock Cylinder Spins Freely
By Ghulam Mustafa March 28, 2026
What does it mean if your lock cylinder spins freely? Learn the causes, quick fixes, and when to call a locksmith to restore your security fast.
More Posts