What Should I Do if I Lost My Keys or If They’ve Been Stolen?

May 16, 2023

It happens to everyone. You’re in a rush to get out the door, but your keys have disappeared! After frantically searching for your keys for what seems like hours, they show up eventually. But other times they are lost. Perhaps you left them somewhere in New York City or they’ve been stolen. Not only is losing your keys time-consuming and stressful, but sometimes it can put your family in danger if they fall into the wrong hands. The best way to prevent the worst-case scenario is to call a locksmith near you. 

 

If you live in Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens, or Staten Island and are looking for a reputable locksmith, look no further than Brothers Locksmith!

 

What to Do if My Keys Were Stolen?

The moment when you first realize that your keys were stolen is always the worst. Although you may be worried about the security of your family, employees, or possessions, it’s imperative to take a deep breath and try to remain calm. Here’s what you can do:

 

Call the Proper Authorities

Now that your keys have fallen into the wrong hands, you’ll want to do everything in your power to prevent any immediate danger. File a police report with your local authorities as soon as possible. If your purse or wallet was stolen along with your keys, you become at risk for identity theft. 

 

Hire a Locksmith to Change the Locks

After contacting the police, immediately call a reputable locksmith to come and change or rekey your locks. Your locksmith will advise you on the best course of action. You can also use this opportunity to upgrade your locks to high-security or smart locks.

 

What to Do if I Lost My Keys?

Losing your keys can be quite frustrating, especially if you’ve been locked out or have somewhere to be. They can get lost in cluttered homes, fall out of purses or pockets, and slip out of hands easily. Luckily, losing your keys isn’t as serious as if someone stole them. Here’s what you should do once you realize that you’ve misplaced your car key, house key, or another key:

 

Check for an Alternative Entry

Trying to get into your home or business? It’s possible that you left a door or window unlocked. Check all entrances and windows on floor levels, you may get lucky!

 

Look for a Spare Key

Do you have a spare key in a place that you can easily access? Did you give a backup key out to any of your neighbors, friends, or family members? If you have a spare key in a hidden lockbox, in a wallet, or purse, now’s the time to use it. If you left one with a trusted individual, contact them and ask them when you can get it. 

 

Call a Locksmith

If no entrances have been left unlocked or you don’t have a spare key, call a locksmith to get you back into your home, business, or car. A professional locksmith can get you back in without damaging your locks. Talk to your locksmith about cutting you a spare key on-site, so you can prevent future lockouts . If you’re worried about a stranger finding your keys, discuss your options with them.  

 

Call Brothers Locksmith

If you live in New York City, give Brothers Locksmith a call! Brothers Locksmith has been serving the residents of New York City since 2008! We’re more than happy to help you out whether you’ve lost your keys, they’ve been stolen, or if you’re experiencing other key and lock-related issues. If your keys have been stolen, we may advise taking drastic measures like getting your locks rekeyed or changed to protect your family (or employees) and property. We understand that every situation is unique and will address yours accordingly. If you’re located in Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens, or Staten Island, we can send one of our locksmiths over to you within minutes!

Call Us Any Time!

Call Now
Why Car Keys Become Difficult to Insert
By Rabia Tingat • October 31, 2026
Car key hard to insert or sticking in the lock? Learn why keys get stiff, from wear and dirt to rust and cold, and how to fix it before it breaks.
Why Your Trunk Won't Open Even With the Key
By Rabia Tingat • October 28, 2026
Trunk won't open even with the key? Learn the common causes, from a dead fob to a broken cable, plus how to open it from inside and when to call a pro.
Commercial Door Hardware Problems That Affect Security
By Rabia Tingat • October 24, 2026
Door closers, latches, hinges, and panic bars can fail quietly. Learn the warning signs, a 5-minute check, and when to call a locksmith.
How to Secure Shared Office Spaces
By Rabia Tingat • October 21, 2026
Learn how to secure shared office spaces, from entry access and visitor rules to key cards, locks, and move-out rekeying. Steps for tenants and landlords.
Why Your Spare Car Key Doesn't Work Properly
By Rabia Tingat • October 19, 2026
Spare car key won't start the car or unlock the doors? Learn why spare keys fail, from bad cuts to unprogrammed chips, and how to fix it fast.
Signs Your Ignition Cylinder Is Failing
By Rabia Tingat • October 16, 2026
Key stuck, hard to turn, or car won't start? Learn the signs of a failing ignition cylinder, what causes it, and what to do before you get stranded.
The Importance of Restricted Key Systems
By Rabia Tingat • October 14, 2026
Restricted key systems stop unauthorized copies. Learn how restricted keyways, patents, and authorization work, and if your business needs one.
Why Businesses Need Key Control Policies
By Rabia Tingat • October 12, 2026
A key control policy shows who holds keys, who can copy them, and what happens when one is lost. Learn what to include and who should own it.
More Posts